Montana
$183
Income shares · monthly
- Annual
- $2,196
- Dense rank
- #6
Compare different states
2026
2026Montana vs New York Child Support
Montana and New York both estimate $183/mo on the vignette.
By Sammy S. · Founder · AuthorUpdated for 2026
Key finding
Montana and New York tie on monthly estimate
Both estimate $183/mo on $5,000 / $3,000 monthly gross · 2 children · Parent A 70% custody · Parent B pays. Income-shares ties often reflect this hub’s simplified shared schedule.
Side-by-side child support scoreboard
New York
$183
Income shares · monthly
- Annual
- $2,196
- Dense rank
- #6
Key takeaways — Montana vs New York
- Montana and New York both estimate about $183/mo on $5,000 / $3,000 monthly gross · 2 children · Parent A 70% custody · Parent B pays.
- Montana: Income shares. New York: Income shares.
- Dense ranks: Montana #6; New York #6 (#1 = highest monthly estimate).
- If either side uses income shares, remember this hub’s simplified shared schedule can cause ties that official worksheets would not.
- Personalize at /child-support-calculator.
Rule contrast (2026)
| Topic | Montana | New York |
|---|---|---|
| Guideline model | Income shares | Income shares |
| Vignette monthly | $183 | $183 |
| Vignette annual | $2,196 | $2,196 |
| Dense rank | #6 | #6 |
| Guideline citation | Montana Child Support Guidelines (Melson Formula) — Admin. R. Mont. 37.62.101 et seq. | New York Child Support Standards Act (CSSA), Dom. Rel. Law § 240(1-b) |
| Official resource | https://dphhs.mt.gov/csed | https://www.childsupport.ny.gov/dcse/child_support_standards.html |
Paying-parent income ladder
| Parent B gross | MT monthly | NY monthly | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| $2,000 | $0 | $25 | $25 |
| $3,000 | $183 | $183 | $0 |
| $5,000 | $536 | $536 | $0 |
| $8,000 | $701.54 | $701.54 | $0 |
How to read Montana vs New York
Montana vs New York child support in 2026
This page compares guideline estimates for Montana (MT) and New York (NY) on $5,000 / $3,000 monthly gross · 2 children · Parent A 70% custody · Parent B pays, calculated from our engine.
Monthly estimates tie at about $183. That often means both rows use the simplified income-shares schedule — not that official tables are identical.
Montana uses an income-shares guideline model (NCSL). This hub’s engine uses a simplified shared income-shares schedule — many income-shares states therefore tie on the locked vignette. Montana uses the Melson Formula — one of only three states (with Delaware and Hawaii). The Melson Formula provides a self-support reserve for each parent and ensures children share in higher parental income. This calculator uses a simplified income shares approximation — actual Montana Melson Formula results may differ. Use Montana DPHHS for precise calculations.
New York uses an income-shares guideline model (NCSL). This hub’s engine uses a simplified shared income-shares schedule — many income-shares states therefore tie on the locked vignette. New York CSSA formula: 17%/25%/29%/31%/35%+ of combined income up to $193,000/year (March 2026 cap). Non-custodial parent pays their proportional income share of that obligation. Estimates vary by ±10-20% due to court discretion on above-cap income. Use official NY courts worksheet for precise calculations.
Guideline model contrast
Montana citation: Montana Child Support Guidelines (Melson Formula) — Admin. R. Mont. 37.62.101 et seq.. New York citation: New York Child Support Standards Act (CSSA), Dom. Rel. Law § 240(1-b).
Profiles: /child-support-by-state/montana and /child-support-by-state/new-york.
Not legal advice — court worksheets and agency calculators control.
How the gap can change with income
The ladder below recomputes monthly estimates as Parent B’s gross monthly income changes (Parent A income and custody stay at vignette defaults).
Percentage-of-income states often scale more steeply with obligor income than the simplified income-shares schedule.
Limits of this comparison
No invented per-state income-shares table numbers. Melson/hybrid accuracy notes still apply where relevant.
Health insurance, childcare add-ons, and multi-family credits are omitted on the ranking vignette.
Who this comparison helps
Useful if…
- •Parents weighing Montana vs New York orientation numbers
- •Editors illustrating percentage-of-income vs income-shares gaps
- •Users deciding which state calculator to open next
Use official tools if…
- •Treating a hub tie as identical official guidelines
- •Litigation strategy without counsel
- •Interstate jurisdiction questions beyond this vignette
Comparison checklist
- 1Confirm models: Income shares vs Income shares.
- 2Read accuracy notes on both state profiles.
- 3Run custom incomes at /child-support-calculator.
- 4Cross-check each state’s official calculator.
What the monthly gap means
Identical vignette estimates — often because both use the simplified income-shares schedule. Official worksheets can still differ.
Limits of this comparison
We do not invent per-state income-shares table numbers. Melson/hybrid notes, add-ons, and deviations may change real outcomes. Use each state’s official calculator.
Montana vs New York child support FAQs
Montana and New York tie at about $183/mo on this vignette (often because both use the simplified income-shares schedule).
Montana: Income shares (Montana Child Support Guidelines (Melson Formula) — Admin. R. Mont. 37.62.101 et seq.). New York: Income shares (New York Child Support Standards Act (CSSA), Dom. Rel. Law § 240(1-b)).
No. This educational engine shares one simplified income-shares schedule across those states. Official tables, worksheets, and deviations differ — confirm with each state’s calculator.
Not necessarily. Recompute with the income ladder on this page or the child support calculator — percentage-of-income and income-shares paths scale differently.
Both estimate the same monthly on this vignette; open each official calculator to see how real worksheets diverge.
No. Educational engine output only. Courts apply official guidelines and evidence.
Compare another pair
Compare any two states
Guideline estimates on $5,000 / $3,000 monthly gross · 2 children · Parent A 70% custody · Parent B pays.
Related child support comparisons
Related tools
Child support calculatorModel any incomes, custody, and stateChildcare cost by stateCenter-based infant and preschool costsChild tax credit calculatorFederal CTC / ACTC estimatesUS paycheck calculatorFederal, state, and FICA take-homeDTI calculatorDebt-to-income with support paymentsState tax compareSide-by-side state income tax