Tax Calculator

Paycheck Tax Calculator

All Plans

Income-Driven Repayment Calculator

Compare every federal IDR plan side by side — RAP, IBR, ICR, PAYE, and SAVE — with your actual numbers. See monthly payments, forgiveness timelines, and which plans are actually available to you right now.

By Sammy S. · Founder · AuthorUpdated for 2026

RAPIBRICRPAYESAVEFree · No signup
Plan Status Overview — March 2026
What each plan is, and whether you can enroll today
RAP
New Jul 2026

1–10% of AGI. $50/dependent reduction. Replaces SAVE/PAYE/REPAYE for new borrowers.

Forgiveness: TBD by ED rulemaking

IBR
Active

10% (new borrowers) or 15% (old borrowers) of discretionary income. Capped at standard payment.

Forgiveness: 20 yr (new) / 25 yr (old)

ICR
Active

20% of discretionary income (uses 100% FPL). The only IDR option for Parent PLUS consolidation.

Forgiveness: 25 years

PAYE
Closed to new

10% of discretionary income, capped at standard payment. Closed to new applicants Oct 2023.

Forgiveness: 20 years

SAVE
Court-suspended

Blocked by federal court injunction since Aug 2024. Borrowers in interest-free forbearance.

Forgiveness: N/A

Compare Your IDR Options
$

Your line 11 on Form 1040

$
%

You + spouse + dependents. Affects poverty-line calculation.

$50/year reduction per child under RAP only.

Old (15%)New (10%)
How to use this calculator
1Enter your AGI — find it on line 11 of your 1040. Use last year's if you haven't filed yet.
2Enter your total federal loan balance and interest rate. Check studentaid.gov for exact figures.
3Set household size (you + family members). This affects the poverty-line calculation for IBR/PAYE/ICR.
4Select IBR borrower type: "New" if your first federal loan was July 1, 2014 or later.
Key differences

RAP vs IBR

IBR subtracts 150% of the poverty line before applying its rate, making it lower for most single borrowers. RAP's advantages: $50/dependent reduction, no eligibility test, and it's the default plan for new borrowers after July 2026.

IBR cap matters

IBR is capped at your standard 10-year payment. If your income is high enough, IBR = standard payment, so there's no benefit to enrolling.

ICR is for Parent PLUS

Direct Loan borrowers almost never benefit from ICR — it uses 100% of poverty line and 20% rate, making it the most expensive IDR option in most cases.

SAVE is suspended — here's what that actually means for you

If you're enrolled in SAVE, your loans are in administrative forbearance — meaning no payments are required and interest is not accruing. This sounds fine until you realize that months in forbearance do not count toward income-driven forgiveness or Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF).

Borrowers chasing 20- or 25-year IDR forgiveness are effectively frozen in time. Borrowers chasing PSLF have a partial workaround — the Department of Education has indicated forbearance months may count for PSLF purposes, but this is subject to ongoing litigation. Don't assume it.

What to do if you're in SAVE right now:

  • If you're not pursuing PSLF, consider switching to IBR or RAP (once available) to restart forgiveness clock
  • If you're pursuing PSLF, verify your certifications are up to date and monitor ED guidance closely
  • Don't make extra payments during forbearance if pursuing forgiveness — they reduce your balance but don't advance the forgiveness clock, and interest isn't growing so there's no interest-cost benefit either

There's a hidden trap with IBR that catches higher earners

IBR is capped at the standard 10-year payment amount. This sounds like a safety net — and it is — but it also means that if your income grows high enough, you end up paying the same amount as standard repayment while being "enrolled in IDR."

At that point you get all the downsides of IDR (forgiveness interest risk, annual recertification requirement, longer repayment term) with none of the payment reduction benefit. And the forgiveness clock is still running at 20 or 25 years, meaning you'll likely pay the loan in full before forgiveness applies.

Example — when IBR stops helping:

$40,000 loan at 6.53% → standard 10-yr payment ≈ $454/month. If your IBR calculation comes to $500/month (capped at $454), you're paying $454 whether you're on IBR or not. At that income level, just staying on standard repayment is cleaner.

Why RAP's math is fundamentally different from every other IDR plan

Every other IDR plan (IBR, PAYE, ICR) uses the same underlying concept: calculate your discretionary income by subtracting some multiple of the poverty line, then take a percentage of that. RAP throws out this approach entirely.

RAP applies a percentage directly to your total AGI — no poverty-line subtraction first. This makes RAP more expensive than IBR for most single borrowers with no dependents, because IBR subtracts 150% of the poverty line ($23,475 for a single person in 2026) before applying its 10% rate. The numbers make this concrete:

AGIRAP /moIBR /mo (new)
$30,000~$75~$54
$50,000~$260~$221
$75,000~$527~$429
$100,000~$833~$638

Single person, household of 1, no dependents. IBR uses 2026 poverty line ($15,650). Below ~$23,475 AGI, IBR = $0 (discretionary income is zero).

IBR is consistently lower than RAP for a single borrower with no dependents. So why does RAP exist? Because IBR requires "partial financial hardship" eligibility and has an enrollment process. RAP is the new default — no eligibility test. And for borrowers with dependents, RAP's $50/child reduction can meaningfully close the gap. If you're currently on IBR and eligible to stay, run your numbers before switching to RAP.

Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about IDR plans and how to compare them

For most single borrowers with no dependents, IBR typically produces a lower payment than RAP, because IBR subtracts 150% of the federal poverty line (~$23,475 for a single person in 2026) before applying its rate. RAP applies its rate directly to your full AGI. RAP can win if you have dependents (each child reduces RAP payment by $50/year) or if your household is large enough that IBR's poverty-line subtraction still leaves a high payment. Use the calculator above — the right answer depends entirely on your specific numbers.

For IBR and PAYE, discretionary income = your AGI minus 150% of the federal poverty guideline for your household size. For ICR, it's AGI minus 100% of the poverty line. So for a single person in 2026, IBR discretionary income = AGI minus about $23,475 (150% × $15,650). RAP doesn't use discretionary income — it applies a percentage directly to your AGI.

No on both. SAVE has been blocked by federal courts since August 2024 — if you're enrolled, you're in administrative forbearance. PAYE was closed to new applicants in October 2023. If you're already enrolled in either plan, you can stay, but no new applications are being accepted for SAVE and new PAYE enrollment is not available.

Almost exclusively Parent PLUS borrowers. ICR is the only income-driven plan accessible to Parent PLUS loans (after Direct Consolidation). For regular Direct Loans, ICR is generally the most expensive IDR option — IBR or RAP will almost always be cheaper.

No. If you're already enrolled in IBR, you stay on IBR unless you choose to switch. RAP becomes the default for new borrowers starting July 1, 2026, and for anyone who enrolls in an IDR plan after that date. You can opt into RAP, but you're not automatically moved.

Under current law, forgiven amounts on IBR, PAYE, and ICR are generally treated as taxable income in the year of forgiveness (with some exceptions, like PSLF). RAP forgiveness tax treatment is still being determined through the rulemaking process. Always consult a tax advisor when approaching forgiveness.

Household size affects IBR, PAYE, and ICR — it's used to calculate your poverty line threshold (bigger household = higher poverty line = lower discretionary income = lower payment). Dependent children is used specifically by RAP, which gives a $50/year reduction per dependent child — it's a separate and additional benefit from the income-based payment reduction.
Sources & Official Resources
Federal Student Aid: Income-Driven Repayment PlansFederal Student Aid: IBR Plan detailsFederal Student Aid: ICR Plan detailsFederal Student Aid: SAVE Plan (currently suspended)

IDR plans are administered by the U.S. Department of Education. Calculations are estimates — actual payments are set by your loan servicer.

Related calculators